This is a hard one as well, unless I’m not quite understanding properly I’m not sure if I agree with at least point 2.
I think I like a verified and unverified vote better as this feels as though you are weighing peoples votes on how many ICX they have. There could be a new person that has just found out about ICON and wants to contribute but can’t afford much ICX but with the proposed system his review wouldn’t be as valued as a whale who may be out to cause problems. It just feels like the proposed system would be biased to valuing people’s reviews based on the size of their wallets.